The cost of caring: Welfare state, affordability and independence

The cost of social protection, and the impact of independence, took centre stage at Scotland Tonight debate.


The future of the welfare state - its structure, priorities and affordability - was at the heart of the second Scotland Tonight debate on independence.

Social protection budgets represent almost 40% of all public spending in Scotland, more than health and education expenditure combined.

On Thursday night, Deputy First Minister Nicola Sturgeon and Scottish Labour deputy leader Anas Sarwar clashed over what a Yes vote in the 2014 referendum would mean for the welfare state.

The social democratic consensus in Scotland has always prized the protection of the vulnerable, in particular the infirm, the elderly, the unemployed and the disabled. However, questions about how much the state should do and how key services can be funded have loomed large in this age of austerity. The referendum has only thrown these issues into sharper relief.

David Phillips of the independent think tank the Institute for Fiscal Studies (IFS) said: "A large part of benefit spending goes on older people, so as the population ages that will put increasing pressure on the welfare budget. And with the population expected to age more rapidly in Scotland, this could occur more quickly in Scotland than the rest of the UK."

According to the IFS, welfare spending in Scotland sat at £17.2bn in 2011/12, with £6.3bn going to fund state pensions. Other prominent expenditures included £1.7bn for housing benefit, £1.3bn for disability living allowance and £752m for pension credit.

These benefits are the responsibility of the UK Government. The Scottish Government is responsible for additional expenditures, such as £427m for free personal care and £249m for concessionary travel. A further £5bn is managed by local authorities throughout Scotland.

Supporters of independence point to the apparent discrepancy between what Scotland puts into the UK Treasury and what it receives in return. Scotland, they underscore, contributed 9.9% of all UK revenues in 2011/12 while enjoying only 9.3% of total public expenditure.

Supporters of the union, however, highlight figures showing that Scotland receives £1200 per-capita-per-annum more than the UK as a whole, adding that benefit spending is two percent higher north of the Border and four percent higher on old-age benefits.

The UK Government's pension plans will see a new flat-rate pension of £144 per week from 2016, although coalition ministers have said they cannot pledge that the "triple lock" - the guarantee that the state pension will rise by the earnings, inflation or 2.5% - will continue beyond the current Parliament.

Private-sector pensions are also a key issue for many, with some final salary schemes running significant shortfalls. Regulation has been touted at the EU level that would require companies operating cross-border final salary schemes to address these deficits at the point of independence.

David Wood, from the Institute of Chartered Accountants of Scotland, told Scotland Tonight: "If you'd to fund the deficit on day one or if you have a period as short as three years, the figures that we're talking about, you really are talking about businesses, employers going bust trying to fill from the pension scheme. So it's a huge issue."

Beyond pensions, there are other important payments. Scots take 10.9%, or £1.37bn, of the disability living allowance budget, while making up 8.6% of the UK population. Scotland's incapacity benefit bill sits at £564m, or 11.4% of the overall British expenditure. Employment and support allowance costs £381m, or 10.7% of the UK-wide spend.

However, the issue that has to come dominate the welfare debate, and, for some, to symbolise the divergent values of the Scottish political consensus and the UK Government, is the "bedroom tax". The reform reduces the housing benefit received by those living in social rented accommodation deemed to be under-occupied.

The SNP has pledged to abolish the reform in the first year of an independent Scotland, while Scottish Labour has called on the Scottish Government to set up a £50m fund to mitigate the impact of the change on tenants.

The question of what the welfare state should do and how it should be funded will continue to play a prominent role in the referendum debate. For some, it is about abstract facts and figures; for others, it is about their financial wellbeing; and for others still, it goes to the heart of what kind of country Scotland is and what kind of country it should be.

One account. All of STV.

This field is required. That doesn't look like a valid e-mail format, please check. That e-mail's already in our system. Please try again.
Forgot password?
This field is required. At least 6 characters please. Did you enter your details correctly?
If you've forgotten your details then use the 'Forgot password?' link.
Need to reset your password?

We'll send a link to reset your password to

We've sent you details on how to reset your password

Please check your email and follow the instructions.

Forgotten your email address?

Have you forgotten the email address that you previously joined with? Don't worry, by emailing we can help.

One account. All of STV.

This field is required. Please enter at least 2 characters
This field is required. Please enter at least 2 characters
At least 6 characters please
This field is required. At least 6 characters please.
You have to be 16 or over to join
This field is required. This doesn't appear to be a valid date
Type your full postcode and select your address This field is required. It doesn't look like you've entered a valid postcode. Can't find your address? Confirm the details you've given us are correct by clicking here

By continuing you agree to our Terms of Use, including our Privacy Policy and Cookie Policy. Any issues contact us.

Upload Profile Picture

Please make sure your image is under 2mb in size and a valid JPG, PNG or GIF.

Are you sure?

Unfortunately, you'll be unable to access our premium content. We’ll be sorry to see you go, but if you change your mind you can rejoin us at any time.

Please verify your STV account

Please verify your STV account using the email we sent you. If you have lost the email, we can send you another one, just click the button below.


We've sent you a new verification email.
Please check your email and follow the instructions to verify your account.

Welcome to STV
Thanks for joining us.


Sorry, you must be at least 12 years old to place a vote for your Real Hero.

Please review our Voting Terms of Use for more information.


Sorry! It seems that you are using a browser that is incompatible with our voting service.

To register your vote please copy the below URL in to your regular mobile browser. We recommend Google Chrome, or Safari.


Sorry, you seem to have already voted in this category.

Thanks for voting

Now share your vote with friends on your social network

Share on twitter Share on facebook

Cast your vote

Please register or sign in to continue.

Cast your vote

This field is required. This doesn't appear to be a valid date

Cast your vote

Please fill out this form to cast your vote. As you are under 16 years old you will not create an STV account. Why do we need these details?

This field is required. Please enter at least 2 characters
This field is required. Please enter at least 2 characters
This field is required. That doesn't look like a valid e-mail format, please check.
Location This field is required.
Parental Consent This field is required.

That's you. All that's left is to click the 'Submit Vote' button below. By doing so, you confirm that you and your parent or guardian have read and accept our Voting Terms of Use, Privacy Policy and Cookie policy, and that the details you have entered are correct. We'll look after them as carefully as if they were our own.